ABOUT THE STUDY
Based on Anonymous Field Records from Deer Stalkers
Nicholas J. Aebischer, Christopher J. Wheatley, Hugh R. Rose.
The amount of wounding during routine culling is an important factor in the welfare of wild deer. Little information exists on factors determining shooting accuracy and wounding rates under field conditions in the UK.
In this study, 102 anonymous stalkers collected data on the outcomes and circumstances of 2281 shots. Using hot-deck imputation and generalised linear mixed modelling, we related the probability that a shot hit its target, and the probability that the shot killed the deer if it was hit, to 28 variables describing the circumstances of the shot.
Overall, 96% of deer were hit, of which 93% were killed outright. A reduced probability of hitting the target was associated with an uncomfortable firing position, too little time available, shooting off elbows or freehand, taking the head or upper neck as point of aim, a heavily obscured target, a distant target, shooting at females, lack of shooting practice and a basic (or no) stalker qualification.
An increase in the likelihood of wounding was associated with an uncomfortable firing position, shooting with insufficient time, a distant target (only when time was not sufficient), a bullet weight below 75 grains, a target concealed in thicket or on the move and an area rarely stalked.
To maximise stalking success and deer welfare, we recommend that stalkers ensure a comfortable firing position, use a gun rest, aim at the chest, use bullets heavier than 75 grains, avoid taking a rushed shot, shoot a distant animal only if there is plenty of time, fire only when the target is stationary, avoid shooting at an obscured animal, take care when the ground is unfamiliar, and do shooting practice at least once a month. The high miss rate of basic-level stalkers suggests that training should include additional firing practice under realistic shooting conditions.
This data for this study was collected in 2005 by BDS and forms the basis for ongoing improvements to Best Practice and BDS training. The data was statistically analysed and the paper published in 2014 online by PLOS one
FURTHER READING
BDS Hot Topic Discussion Panels at The Stalking Show 2025
Join us at the dedicated stage in the Sandylands Centre at The Stalking Show 2025 for two expert-led panels, hosted by BDS Chairman Hugh van Cutsem. These sessions will tackle some of the most challenging issues in deer management today — expect lively debate, fresh insights, and time for audience questions.
Pioneering Venison Initiative in Scotland
A pioneering initiative in Scotland is tackling both deer overpopulation and food insecurity by distributing sustainably sourced venison to food banks. The project, led by organisations like Fair Feast, processes venison from responsibly culled deer, providing a nutritious and locally sourced food option while supporting conservation efforts. This innovative approach helps restore natural habitats, manage wildlife responsibly, and offer high-quality protein to communities in need.
A Life Among Deer: Reflections from the Countryside – Part One
Barry Luckhurst’s lifelong connection to the countryside has shaped his deep understanding of deer and wildlife management. In this first instalment of A Life Among Deer, Barry reflects on his early experiences, from growing up surrounded by rural traditions to his first encounters with deer at Mersham Hatch Estate. With a keen eye for detail and an insatiable thirst for knowledge, he explores the intricacies of deer behaviour, the impact of weather on wildlife, and the delicate balance of conservation. This article offers a fascinating glimpse into the lessons learned from a lifetime in the field.
